Our Staff
Kelley Sewell
Senior Pastor
Pastor Kelley earned a bachelors degree in Pastoral Ministries from Taylor Fort Wayne, a Masters of Ministry degree from Bethel University, and is ordained with the Missionary Church. Kelley was thrilled to accept the position of Senior Pastor at Beulah Missionary in 2022. Most importantly, Pastor Kelley is a Shepherd and Teacher at Heart. He absolutely loves his Lord and Savior and the Word of God. Pastor Kelley is very blessed to be married to Kelly (Kelly-girl) and they have three amazing young daughters.
Mike Fisher
Pastor of Family Ministries
Mike is a graduate of Bethel University. He grew up not too far away from here, Mike loves getting into the Word and sharing the impact God can have on you even in the simplest of ways. Mike loves playing ping pong and going to his favorite fast-food restaurant, Taco Bell. Mike began his new position in 2025 overseeing youth, children, and other pastoral duties.
Jim Bennett
Worship Leader
Dr. Jim Bennett is a graduate of Bethel University, IU, and Oakland City University. Jim has taught at all levels, elementary through the university, and is currently the Program Director and Department Chair for Education at Bethel University. Jim and his wife, Alisa, are the parents of Jimmy (Katie) and Johnny (Annie) and have 2 grandchildren.
Liz Brow
LIFE Preschool Director
Liz Brow has formal education and experience in Elementary Education and Nonprofit Business Administration, She has been attending Beulah Missionary Church since 2023, where she has found a welcoming and supportive faith family. She asssumed the position of Preschool Director in 2025.
When she's not working or involved in church activities, Liz enjoys spending quality time with her husband and their five children. In her free time, Liz is an avid traveler, enjoys going for runs, and loves volunteering at her daughters' dance studio. She is also a big Elvis Presley fan.
Jessica Shaffer
Raising Up Leaders Cooperative Founder and Director
Jessica has been married to her best friend Jacob since 2010, and they share 6 wonderful children together. She is a graduate from Bethel College in 2010 with a BS in Nursing. She isn’t currently working as a nurse and has been a stay at home mom since 2020. She has homeschooled all of her children since they were able to begin school and has a passion for sharing her love for homeschooling with the community. In the fall of 2024 Raising Up Leaders Cooperative was born. and now serves over 100 families. RULC is a passion project and Jessica truly enjoys getting to know each of the students who enroll. She wants to create a valuable experience where the students learn about Jesus, make friends, are encouraged to be leaders in their communities, and have fun learning.
Jackie Smith
Office Manager
Jackie became our Office Manager once again in July 2016. (Jackie was our office manager for 5 1/2 years and then took a break.) Her husband, Bryon, is pastor of New Paris Church of the Nazarene. Jackie graduated from Trevecca Nazarene University with a major in chemistry. She and Bryon have 2 adult sons, David and Ben, who is married to Kelli and a granddaughter, Eden.
Kimberly Utt
Housekeeping Manager
Kim, Chris, and their 8 children have been attending BMC since 2018. Kim grew up in the Missionary Church and her father is the senior pastor at New Hope Fellowship Missionary Church. She and her young adult daughters have been keeping the church very clean since 2019.
